Talk:Supplier's Demand/@comment-95.90.47.68-20130906012755/@comment-4613046-20130906135634

It looks like you posted in several pages regarding this, so I'll just answer what looks like the first post.

"What are these negative but amusing results when handing in a forgery and what happens if you give her a cursed carving?"
 * Personally, I don't know. From what I understand however the idea behind giving them an idol goes back to their quest. Caxton/Madeleine ask you to fetch them an idol so they can present it to some Master weaponsmith in order to get access to his wares. The better the idol, the better the wares. Obviously giving the worst idol results in embarrassing Caxton/Madeleine. I can only imagine that they will blame the player for giving them a phony or crappy idol and hold resentment to you in the future.

"... someone said that she'd move to the fields if handed a gold idol - is there any truth to that?"
 * Yes and no. Let me explain: Whether you give a Gold Idol or not, is not related to if she moves to the field or not. Giving gold idol =/= moving to the fields. Madeleine only moves to the fields if you fail to do her quest; Bad Business. By fail, I mean picking up the quest and then not completing it.

I hope that answers your question.