Talk:Gold Idol/@comment-70.197.200.217-20141120011026/@comment-24458380-20141120033256

I recommend giving Caxton the Gold Idol on your first playthrough because of his superior inventory selection. You'll main his expanded inventory on every subsequent New Game+ from then on.

Give Madeleine the Silver Idol on your first playthrough, then give her the Gold Idol next time. Once you give each of them an authentic Gold Idol after 2 playthroughs (first playthrough and one New Game+), you will ALWAYS have access to those expanded inventories granted by the Gold Idols.