Talk:Search Party/@comment-26317522-20150428070601/@comment-5847779-20150428125506

Hm, it's possible that you need the pages from the same playthrough, either all from the first or all from the second or subsequent playthroughs.

Meaning you need to collect not only numbers 5 and 6, but the other ones as well in the same playthrough. If they have different item id's they don't count towards completing the quest if they are from different playthroughs. It shouldn't be that way, but that's the only thing I can think of.