Talk:Witch's Brew/@comment-5493648-20130203180829

"You cannot get a  Herb Ale  during or directly after the quest  Lost and Found . Selene will not allow you to offer her anything. You must wait until you've completed  Lure of the Abyss  and are able to take Wyrm Hunt Quest '' ." ''

I have not completed Lure of the Abyss yet (though I did initiate the convo with Barnaby at the Pawn Guild) but she made me the ale no problem. She was sleeping in front of the fireplace.....easiness.