Talk:Supplier's Demand/@comment-122.176.207.151-20120706190510/@comment-2080866-20120706191100

You can give any idol to complete the quest, not just the regular Gold Idol. You can give bronze, silver, gold, or a forgery of any of them to complete the quest.

If this is your first playthrough, I recommend giving Caxton the Gold idol and the other a bronze or silver idol for the largest benefit. Then during your NG+, give the other the Gold Idol and Caxton any of them. His stock will not change.