User blog comment:Chalxsion/I got Madeleine.../@comment-4999100-20120725050113

I got the innkeeper my first playthrough :-(. Not entirely understanding the affinity system the first time. I cracked up when he showed up being chased by goblins during the Grigori encounter. Then ***spoilers here*** sleeping with him at the end :(. I was sure to get the right NPC on my second playthrough after that. This time being Quina.