Talk:Second Key To Salvation/@comment-98.242.39.248-20120606025519

On my first playthrough, I forced the key from the dude and the key works.

Now I am on NG+ and this time I bought the key, but I think the dude gave me the first key to salvation and now I can't open the door because I need the second key. Anybody know how to fix it? I don't think Black Cat works because he only sells back what you sold, not if you never obtained the item in the first place.