Talk:Silver Idol/@comment-60.225.163.169-20120821132311

A NOTE: (as far as I know...)

Upon giving them the (real) idol, wait up to three (in-game) days and their stock will refresh with new items for sale.

Only the real idols work on either Madeleine or Caxton for this to happen. The forged idols did nothing for me.

Madeleine will only get "Supply & Demand" (the quest where they ask for this idol) if she has set up shop across from the Black Cat (forgery shop) in the Venery (also, as far as I know). If she is for whatever reason still wandering around Gransys / Gran Soren as a wandering merchant, she will not present this quest for you. (She should have set up shop after the quest "Chasing Shadows").

Caxton should offer this quest immediately after you are invited to the Duke's Demesne.