Talk:The Secret Admirer/@comment-5229500-20120717022327

It sounds like it may be "Thick as Thieves" quest being referred to here... I know I had to complete that to get the badge of Amity. If it helps, I was able to do it by killing male bandits in Maul's area by the Witchwood, as I'd killed the cyclops previously. If the cyclops is dead maybe this option will become available as an alternative objective? I never actually ran into Betiah myself and I had killed the cyclops more than once, but was still able to make Ophis my high affinity NPC. If she has been killed she should, IIRC, respawn in time.