Talk:Soulflayer Canyon/@comment-32773874-20170930182333/@comment-24634511-20171001103751

Well both are correct - because it is broken it must have (has) broken..

Even as a native speaker this is such a fine point of grammar I can't say if either is preferable.

Logically "has" implies "is", and so both are equivalent statements.

More would make my head hurt.

(I'll change it to "is" though - maybe it does scan a little better)