Talk:Supplier's Demand/@comment-116.240.244.224-20120610092541/@comment-24.242.121.189-20120919183317

Definitely Caxton. He'll give you loads of new and useful stuff to buy. Madeleine's merchandise is more specialized towards females and daggers/bows.

Forge a fake gold idol. Give the REAL gold idol to Caxton and keep the fake for the discount it'll give you. Give Madeleine any other idol. You can play NG+ (I advise you do) and give Madeleine the real gold idol this time. Give Caxton any idol, it won't downgrade his inventory. I gave him the gold idol my first playthrough, then the silver idol on the second playthrough, and he still sold the gold idol items.