Talk:The Conspirators/@comment-68.105.101.28-20120819174736/@comment-24.20.193.12-20130417201857

I thought you were right so I tested it. Looks like we were both wrong. As soon as you DISCUSS THE VERDICT with Aldous this quest will fail. Most likely you finished up the quest, saw the cut scene, but didn't immediately finish it by discussing it with Aldous.

It's possible that the quest only fails if both Griffin's Bane and T & T are completed, but since that's sort of what the info above says you probably want to remove the note you placed in the walkthrough.