Talk:Search Party/@comment-115.134.181.168-20130826052324

The New Game + notation re: reacquiring the pages or selling then buying back from The Black Cat appears to be false - I had collected 5 of the journal pages in my initial playthrough (forgot to grab the Final Journal Entry), then in my NG+ I picked up the final one, then simply brought all 6 to Reynard. Note that the quest must be the currently selected active one - else you'll simply enter his usual vendor dialogue.

Another note, don't complete the quest until after you've purchased the necessary fake testimonials from him for the quest Trial and Tribulations; many people have reported turning in only the "legit" testimonies is NOT sufficient to guarantee the outcome you wish - although this seems more relevant for those seeking an innocent verdict, as the outcome is slanted towards guilty by default. Also note you may have failed Fournival's kid's quest, which also prevents you from getting her testimonial - thus you will want all the extra supporting testimonies from Reynard.