Talk:Weapon Enchantment/@comment-33780977-20190809094327/@comment-33780977-20190809111502

I wasn't talking about enchantment overriding weapon's innate enchantment - that's obviously true.

I was talking about whether there's a Magick boost applied to permanently enchanted weapon if it is being enchanted with different element, like enchanting Eden's Warden with Holy.

Now, last time I checked enchantments were all about simply adding a specific amount of elemental damage to any weapon affected. Nowhere is mentioned that the element of a weapon enchanted must be the same.

But

Some ppl claim that there will be no Magick boost if element of a weapon and enchantment spell doesn't correspond. That one has to use the same element, like Fire Boon on Eden's Warden or Thunder Enchanter on Caladbolg to increase Magick damage. In the light of what's been said in the article this sounds illogickal to me.

So I ask if someone tested such claims.