Talk:Silver Idol/@comment-213.190.205.153-20121224104520

My Recommendation: Get the Silver Idol and when Caxton asks for a Idol, give the Silver idol and Save the Gold Idol. When Madeleine asks for a idol, give the gold idol to her, as her items are better later on. If you give the gold idol to Caxton, he just sells more variety of weapons (most of them useless really). At post-game the best weapon he will sell is a standard weapon (no idol required for that weapon to be purchased). Same with the armor and everything else.