Talk:Trial and Tribulations/@comment-84.52.49.14-20140911004229/@comment-10707282-20140911052749

It really sounds like you may have mistakenly turned in one or more of the Guilty items, if you're having trouble. It's possibly a mistake of one of Reynard's documents, if you turned any of those in. I've done this quest many many times and I've always found the minimum items decribed above to work for me. Reynard's documents are not at all necessary unless you skip the prerequisites for any of the other documents or you want to use the Chamberlain's Affidavit for the Notice Board Quest.

The only one that cannot be avoided, I think, is the witness testimony. Without that, I think it becomes a game of percentages.